Why this app does less than most
L. P. Benezet, superintendent of schools in Manchester, New Hampshire, stopped
teaching formal arithmetic below the seventh grade in 1929 and taught reading,
reasoning and speaking instead. Within a year those children reached the level that
traditionally taught children had reached after three and a half years of drill —
and they were far better at explaining and applying it.
So this curriculum delays formal arithmetic. Primary 1 to 4 is oral
and physical: counting jump-rope, comparing a pencil to a stick of chalk, guessing
the height of a window and then measuring it. None of that belongs on a
screen, and the app does not offer it. Primary 5 is the first level with
anything here at all, and there is no setting that changes that.
Why this curriculum delays arithmetic — what Benezet actually did,
what his tests showed, and what the experiment does not prove.